Skip to main content
Loading the latest on mortgages, RBA & inflation…
Local Knowledge Finance

Article

Stuck With An Underperforming Investment Property? Decide This Week

Written and reviewed by · Last reviewed

Underperforming investment property? Use this fast, numbers‑first framework to decide whether to hold, refinance, renovate or sell, and what to do next.

Published 8 Sept 2026Updated 25 Sept 2026Reviewed 16 Sept 20266 min read

Key Takeaway

Owners should reassess underperforming investment properties using three tests: cashflow resilience, realistic growth potential, and opportunity cost versus other uses of equity. With negative gearing benefits set to tighten from 1 July 2027, investors should model decisions on pre-tax cashflow and a 3% interest rate stress test. If a property fails these tests, refinancing structure, targeted renovation, or selling and redeploying capital can materially improve long-term wealth; a decision-grade review can usually be done in a week.

Watch the short answer

Can you buy a property before your tax return is done?

If changing a weak investment is on your mind, this video explains how your latest tax return timing affects your next purchase move.

Talk to a broker about your situation
Read the transcript

Think you can't buy a property this year because your accountant hasn't finalised your 2026 tax returns? Think again. If you are a freelancer, a contractor, or a growing business, that means months of lost opportunity. We use alternative documentation pathways that completely bypass the ATO delay. We assess your true borrowing capacity using the last 6 months of your business bank deposits, getting you approved while your competitors are still waiting on paperwork. Stop waiting on tax portals to dictate your property goals. Message me 'ALTDOC', to fast-track your FY27 approval.

General information only, not personal advice. Your situation is assessed before any recommendation.

Stuck With An Underperforming Investment Property? Decide This Week

This topic is covered in full on Tailored Loans Sydney

Underperforming investment property? Use this fast, numbers‑first framework to decide whether to hold, refinance, renovate or sell, and what to do next.

Read the full guide on tailoredloans.sydney

An underperforming investment property is one that fails three tests: 1) sustainable cashflow under a 3% rate rise, 2) reasonable growth prospects, and 3) stacking up against other uses of your equity and energy. If it fails on most of these, you should actively consider refinancing, renovating, or selling rather than just hoping the market bails you out.

Here’s a decision framework you can work through this week.

Checklist comparing hold, renovate or sell options for a property investor Laying out hold, renovate and sell side by side turns vague frustration into a clear decision.

Step 1: Define “underperforming” in your numbers

Before you jump to sell or renovate, quantify the problem.

1. Cashflow test (post‑2027 mindset)
Model the property on pre‑tax numbers assuming little or no wage‑offset negative gearing on established dwellings from 1 July 2027.

Include per year:

  • Rent (after vacancy, say 3–4 weeks per year)
  • Interest (stress‑test at +3% above current rate)
  • Other costs: strata, rates, insurance, maintenance, land tax, management

If you’re running more than about $5,000–$10,000 per year negative with a 3% rate buffer and no tax benefit, the asset needs a strong growth or add‑value story to justify keeping it.

2. Growth potential test
Ask honestly:

  • Is the area’s population and job base growing or flat?
  • Are there major infrastructure or zoning changes coming?
  • Is there a structural issue (oversupply of similar units, flood/flight path, tired complex) that caps demand?

If growth has lagged the broader city for 5–10 years and nothing material is changing, don’t assume the next decade will be different.

3. Opportunity cost test
Estimate your net equity if you sold:

Example: Property worth $850,000, loan $550,000, selling costs/CGT say $80,000 → usable equity around $220,000.

Now ask: could that $220,000 perform better as:

  • A deposit on a different investment, or
  • Debt reduction on your home, or
  • Cash buffer + business growth capital?

If the answer is “almost certainly yes”, you have an underperformer.

Premium insight

The strategy continues below

You've seen the problem and the groundwork — now unlock the exact steps our CPA and Registered Tax Agent-led brokers use, including 3 more sections. Enter your email for instant, free full access.

Free access. No spam — unsubscribe anytime. Your details stay confidential.

Frequently asked questions

You should review each investment property at least once a year and whenever interest rates, rental conditions or your income change significantly. An annual review helps you catch underperformance early, adjust loan structures and avoid holding a dud asset for another 5–10 years out of habit. It doesn’t need to be complex, but it must be consistent.
Decide first whether you are likely to sell, renovate or hold over the next few years. If you’re likely to sell or refinance soon, staying variable or only partially fixing can preserve flexibility. If you’re committed to holding and cashflow is tight, some fixed-rate exposure can provide short-term certainty at the cost of flexibility.
Renovating before selling can be worthwhile if the works are mainly cosmetic, quick to complete and clearly increase the sale price by more than their total cost. Focus on kitchen, bathroom, paint and presentation rather than structural changes. In a strong market you may be better off selling as-is and letting the buyer add their own improvements.

Talk to a broker who is a CPA and Registered Tax Agent

Free consultation, plain-English advice tailored to your situation.

Your details are kept confidential. We'll never share them.

All insights